Aetna Medicare Advantage Plans Review

checkmark Fact checked Reviewed by: Leron Moore, Medicare consultant - Published: April 2, 2021


Quick Aetna Medicare Advantage Plans review: Aetna offers a wide range of health care plans for older adults, including Preferred Provider Organization and Health Maintenance Organization, at a competitive monthly rate.


Aetna, an award-winning health insurance company, was founded in 1853 in Hartford, Connecticut, and is a subsidiary of CVS Health Corporation. It's the third-largest health insurance provider in the nation, with approximately 22.1 million members. It offers affordable monthly premiums and low copays, and it has consistently positive customer feedback. By reviewing Aetna’s available plans and assessing its benefits and drawbacks, you can determine whether Aetna is right for you.

What do Aetna Medicare Advantage Plans cover? 

Aetna Medicare Advantage Plans are comparable in their scope of coverage to other Medicare Advantage Plans, offering all the benefits of Original Medicare, along with coverage for additional health services. Medicare Advantage Plans, also called Medicare Part C, often include prescription drug, vision, and dental coverage and wellness programs. Your out-of-pocket costs depend on the plan you choose, as do rules for how you get services, such as whether you have to choose a primary care doctor or get a referral to see a specialist.

Aetna home page

What are Aetna Medicare Advantage Plan options? 

Aetna has five major Medicare Advantage Plans, although the options available to you may vary based on your location. Of these plans, four of them are PPOs, and one is an HMO. With HMOs, you’re required to choose a primary care physician and get health care services from in-network providers. Because these plans are limited in their coverage, the premiums are typically affordable. In general, PPO plans offer greater flexibility, allowing you to see out-of-network providers and specialists without obtaining referrals. These plans typically have higher premiums.  

While some of Aetna’s Medicare Advantage Plans have no deductible, other plans have deductibles of up to $1,000. The cost to see your primary care doctor ranges from $10 to $20, and the copay for specialists is $45 across all plans. 

Compare these five Aetna Medicare Advantage Plan options:

Aetna Medicare Advantage Plans
Plan Name Monthly premium Annual deductible Office visits Telehealth Emergency room Annual maximum out-of-pocket cost
Aetna Medicare Elite Plan (PPO) $0 $1,000 $10 primary / $45 specialist

$10 $90 $7,550
Aetna Medicare Value Plan (PPO) $22 $0 $10 primary / $45 specialist $10 $90 $7,550
Aetna Medicare Elite Plan 3 (PPO) $39 $1,000 $10 primary / $45 specialist



Aetna Medicare Elite Plan (HMO) $39 $500 $20 primary / $45 specialist $20 $90 $7,550

Aetna Medicare Premier Plan (PPO) $99 $0 $15 primary / $45 specialist $15 $90 $7,550

*Based on pricing in New York, New York 

Pros and cons of Aetna Medicare Advantage plans 

What we like about Aetna Medicare Advantage Plans: Plans: The drawbacks of Aetna Medicare Advantage Plans:

  • Coverage for vision and hearing services 
  • High scores on Medicare’s 5-star rating system 
  • Affordable monthly premiums 

  • Annual out-of-pocket costs are relatively high 
  • Only two plan types to choose from 

Aetna Medicare Advantage Plans reviews and ratings 

Overall, Aetna’s customers give positive feedback regarding their experience with the company and the claims process. Aetna scores consistently well across various consumer review sites. 

Aetna has an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau. In the last three years, the company has closed 619 customer complaints.  

The National Committee for Quality Assurance gives Aetna plans ratings that range between 2.5 and 4.5. Most plans were rated in the mid-to-high performance range across three categories, which include customer satisfaction, how well the plan covers preventative treatments, and the plan’s performance for covering chronic or acute conditions. The majority of plans are accredited through the NCQA. 

Within the last year, Consumer Affairs has logged 1,705 ratings for Aetna. On average, consumers give the company 4 out of 5 stars, with 4- and 5-star ratings making up the bulk of consumer feedback. Among the most common benefits that reviewers commend are Aetna’s competitive rates, friendly and efficient representatives, and reliable coverage.   

Leron headshot
Reviewed by:

Leron Moore, Medicare consultant

Leron Moore has guided Medicare beneficiaries and their families as a Medicare professional for nearly 15 years. First as a Medicare provider enrollment specialist, and now a Medicare account executive, Moore works directly with Medicare beneficiaries to ensure they understand Medicare and Medicare Advantage Plans.